Winter Escape Special: Enjoy 15% off newly booked stays with code WINTER15 at checkout.

Welcome to Bluefish Vacation Rentals & Property Management

Discover unique vacation rental homes, curated experiences and unmatched local expertise along the coast of Southwest Michigan and Indiana.

Choose Your Vacation Rental Home

New Listings Lake Front Pools Short Summer Stays Hot Tubs Dog Friendly Large Groups All Rentals
Book Now

Explore Our Destinations

Just over an hour from downtown Chicago, Bluefish offers the largest portfolio of vacation rental homes in New Buffalo, Union Pier, Lakeside, Harbert, Grand Beach, Sawyer, St. Joseph, Michigan City, Long Beach and more.

Sawyer, Michigan

A must-visit Lake Michigan beach town, Sawyer is home to popular attractions and things to do, like visiting Warren Dunes State Park and a world-class Michigan brewery.

Sawyer, Michigan

A must-visit Lake Michigan beach town, Sawyer is home to popular attractions and things to do, like visiting Warren Dunes State Park and a world-class Michigan brewery.

Sawyer, Michigan

A must-visit Lake Michigan beach town, Sawyer is home to popular attractions and things to do, like visiting Warren Dunes State Park and a world-class Michigan brewery.

New Buffalo Union Pier Lakside Harbert Swayer Grand Beach Three Oaks St. Joseph Michiana Indiana Benton Harbor Stevensvilla
Book Now

Guest Reviews

Darby Cottage

This was a perfect house for our first ever reunion. The great room was a wonderful gathering place for cocktails, conversation and food. Everything was very clean and sparking. We had three generations and there was plenty of space for everyone. The deck on the top floor was wonderful for watching the sunrise and the sunset and also for viewing the “blue moon.” We made good use of the grill and found the kitchen more than adequate for cooking meals. Whenever there was a problem, and it was minor (need toilet paper) Jason appeared within minutes. He was a delight to work with. I would be delighted to recommend this house to anyone who needs a lot of space and large meeting areas.

Carol W. from San Diego, CA

Darby Cottage

This was a perfect house for our first ever reunion. The great room was a wonderful gathering place for cocktails, conversation and food. Everything was very clean and sparking. We had three generations and there was plenty of space for everyone. The deck on the top floor was wonderful for watching the sunrise and the sunset and also for viewing the “blue moon.” We made good use of the grill and found the kitchen more than adequate for cooking meals. Whenever there was a problem, and it was minor (need toilet paper) Jason appeared within minutes. He was a delight to work with. I would be delighted to recommend this house to anyone who needs a lot of space and large meeting areas.

Carol W. from San Diego, CA

Our Partners